Best Tips for Dealing with Sibling Fights

Dealing with Sibling Fights
Dealing with Sibling Fights
Dealing with Sibling Fights

We’ve actually been discussing siblings throughout – so rather than repeating the same information, let’s just recap.

Here’s how to parent siblings:

  • Separate the kids during fights.
  • Give each child a task and redirect to something else.
  • Use an energy-zapping session if necessary.  (See:  Anger Issues in Children.
  • When getting each side of the story, use power phrases (‘Not your turn’, ‘I didn’t ask’, ‘That’s not what I asked’, etc.) and make sure the kids don’t interrupt each other or you.
  • Guide siblings on how to act and what to say in each particular situation.  TELL and SHOW them how to act appropriately.
  • Guide kids on how to vent feelings appropriately.  Make it clear that the feelings are okay but they cannot use actions or words to insult or hurt others.  Use power actions to show them how: “When you’re feeling angry, tell me, Mom, I’m really angry right now and need a few minutes to calm down!”  (OR)  When your brother grabs your game pieces, you need to say, “John, that was rude.  When you do that I don’t feel like playing with you.”   Then make sure and guide John (the pestering sibling) on why he was wrong, how it made his brother feel, and what he should have said and done instead.  Then John needs to apologize and receive a consequence, if necessary.
  • Do not let their brains escalate. STOP the yelling by using power phrases and separation.
  • Make sure your children get plenty of rest, exercise, and activity.
  • Get rid of crappy food!  It makes kids act crappy.
  • Children must have chores and responsibilities.  A chore chart helps tremendously!  Follow it!
  • SCHEDULES are essential!  Define how much time each day the kids have for electronics, TV, play, homework, chores, etc. STICK to it!!

Any of the techniques in these articles can be applied and used with siblings, so have at it ready.

The most important aspect of sibling argument management is redirection during fights.  Separate the kids.  If you’re in the car, make them sit on their hands.  Then make one kid look out his nearest window and the other look out the opposite window.  They need to get their eyes, hands, and focus off of each other.

When not in the car, make them do something physical to zap that energy if needed: jumping jacks, laps around the yard, whatever.  When they are in smart-aleck mode, they may laugh or think it’s fun until they start hurting or get tired.  Then it’s not so fun anymore.  Do not back down.  This is where you make your point.  So don’t cave on me.

Give them positive direction and don’t let the argument slide because you’ve had a long day at work.  TELL them what to say and do in EACH particular situation.  If you don’t tell them, they won’t know!

Sibling Fights

Talk siblings through minor spats so they understand how to work it out.

Example:

Amy:  Hey, stop that!

Sara:  I wasn’t doing anything!

Amy:  Yes you were! You were messing with the thermostat and I just turned it down because it’s hot!

Adult: Hey. What’s going on?

Amy:  Sara just. . .(then Sara interrupts, and they start arguing)

Adult:  Anh!  Sarah, Amy, voices off. Amy, tell me what happened.

Amy: Sara?s trying to mess up the A/C.

Adult: Sara, is that true?

Sara: No, I didn’t do anything!

Adult: Were you touching the thermostat?

Sara: I didn’t think. . .

Adult: (interrupt) I didn’t ask what you were thinking.  I asked if you were touching the thermostat.  Yes or no?

Sara: Yes, but I was just. . . she has it set to seventy five, and it’s not supposed to be that low!

Adult: Okay, then.  If you were touching it, do you see why Amy thinks you were going to change the temperature?

Sara:  Yes.

Adult:  Okay.  Now turn the a/c off completely.  It’s nice outside, so we don’t even need it on.  Open some windows and turn on the fans.  And Amy, the next time you have a problem with what Sara is doing, use better communication.  Tell her, “I just lowered the temperature because I’m hot.”  And if Sara reminds you that it’s not supposed to be that low, don’t get defensive.  If you have a question about the rules, come ask me.

See?  Guide your children on how to resolve arguments. Don’t let the problem escalate. Provide instruction on how to handle each situation.  

 

Review: 

 Create calm authority.

Get kids focused on you and away from escalating behavior.

It’s important for kids to earn respect, earn their way, and earn the extras they want.

Giving too much leads to a difficult future for our children by creating a sense of entitlement, no skills, no character, no motivation, no work ethic, and no clue how to take care of themselves.

End sibling arguments and teach better communication skills.

 

The ABC Guide -A-Action

The ABC Guide - A-Antecedent
ABC Guide -A-Action
The ABC Guide – A-Antecedent

ABC Guide -A-Action , helps you understand your child’s behavior, customize your reaction and determine if your parenting styles for discipline are working.  When the kid is constantly answering your requests with “but I wasn’t. . .” or “he started it. . .” or “you’re so mean!” then guess what?  We’re not the least bit effective.  It’s a kick in the gut, I know, but responses like that mean our discipline methods stink and need to change!

The ABC guide and associated lingo can get annoying sometimes, but you have to understand the foundation.  We’re changing the way we think, so we have to wrap our brains around why.  

Why do kids have smart mouth comebacks, why do we get so worked up, and why is it important to change?  So hold your horses my friend!  Let’s take a couple of chapters to learn the basics and vocabulary first.  It’s easy enough once you get it.  Then we can move on to specific methods to decrease the unwanted behavior.

ABC Guide -A-Action 

Briefly, ABC stands for:

  • A = Antecedent:    The action immediately before the (good or bad) behavior.
  • B = Behavior:         What exactly the kid does and why.
  • C = Consequence: What happens immediately after the behavior.

Now let’s examine this in detail.

A = Antecedent

‘A’  is the event that happens right before the behavior.  Behavior can be desirable or undesirable.  Good or bad.   ‘A’ is the action or thing that causes the good or bad behavior.  Most often it’s requests, actions, or commands from us such as, “I told you not to do that”;  “Turn the computer off, please”;  “Hurry up”;  “Your room still isn’t clean”; etc.

Analyzing the antecedent includes three factors:

1) Identify  ‘A’

What did you say?  What did you do?  What was your child doing?  Figure out your setup.  If the resulting behavior was good, mark it.  Approach it that way again in the future.  If the behavior was bad, avoid that setup.  For example, your kid keeps leaving clothes on the floor in the morning, driving you bonkers.  

Your approach is to yell as soon as you see the clothes.  The response is always a put off: “I’ll get it later,” or “I’m doing something right now,” or back talk, “It’s my room, I can leave it how I want!”  So think about when and where you’re making the request.  Are you in a rush to get to work or school?

 Is the kid distracted, playing a game, or in the middle of another task?  If so, you have to wait until he is focused on you and neither of you are rushed, distracted, or annoyed.

2) Set Crystal-Clear Directions and Expectations

Put simply, it’s our job to make sure we give crystal-clear directions, examples, and expectations in order to get a successful outcome.  We cannot be vague. “Clean your room” can mean one thing to you and something totally different to your kid.  Be specific! “Pick up these clothes.  Put the dirty ones in the laundry and clean ones in the drawer.  Game pieces go in the game box and the game box goes under your bed.”  Break it down into parts and tell them exactly what you want. Write it down if needed.  That way there’s no miscommunication (“But you said I could ……..”)

Give your child very specific directions and guidance so he understands exactly how you want him to behave.  If you don’t tell him what you want, he won’t know.  The behavior will then continue or become worse.

Don’t use isolated, abstract commands: “Cut it out”;   “Stop that, young man”;  “Don’t argue” or  “Enough!” Seriously, you may think kids have a clue as to what you mean, but they aren’t mind readers.  TELL them what you want!  Use specific actions.  For example, for the younger kids, “Cut it out” can mean:

  • Quiet hands –> Use kind words
  • Quiet mouth –> Bottom on the chair, feet on the floor
  • Say please –> Walk beside me
  • Say thank you –> Hands to yourself

“Cut it out” is too vague.  Avoid fuzzy words!  Be clear and teach your child exactly what behavior you want to see. Think about what you WANT.  Be specific and stop telling your child what you don’t want” because that’s a negative.

Here are some examples:

  •   What We Want –> What We Don’t Want
  •   Quiet feet –> No running!
  •   Inside voice –> Stop yelling!
  •   Bottom on the chair –> Quit wiggling!
  •   Food goes in your mouth –> Don’t throw that!
  •   Stay with me –> Don’t run off!
  •   Hands to yourself –> Leave your brother alone!
  •   Four on the floor [chair legs] –> Don’t tilt your chair back! 

See what I mean?  Focus on what you WANT your child to do.  When you always say, “Stop it”  or  “No”  or  “Cut it out,”    (a) it points out the negative, and    (b) it is not specific.   It doesn’t tell them what you want to see instead. And if you don’t tell them what you want, how can you expect them to do it?

3) External Factors

Under  “A”  you also examine external factors such as lack of sleep, distractions, hunger/thirst, etc.  You know your child, so use this information to avoid conflicts and misunderstandings.

For example, your kid is being a crank-pot, but you need help setting the table for dinner.  So you ask nicely and they give you lip.  Avoid barking back, “Don’t you argue with me!   Get over here and help!”  Instead, check yourself. Remember that you’ve been racing the poor kid all over town that week for art class, soccer and piano and he’s still got forty-five minutes of homework to do.  He’s a little stressed and tired!  The expectation doesn’t change – he is still going to help set the table.  You just don’t need to be a tyrant about it and neither does he.  So go over, offer a hand, and say, “Here, I’ll help you.”  

Someone walking in off the street might call you a pushover for tolerating that nonsense, but you understand the day and week the kid is going through, and factor that in.  You know for darn sure that yelling or forcing the kid to obey ‘just because’ will get you nowhere, so go about it a different way to get a positive result.

Don’t give into Immediate Gratification

Immediate Gratification
Immediate Gratification
Immediate Gratification

Do not give in to immediate gratification. Our intent is to make our kids comfortable and happy, but we are actually making their future much, much harder.

My friends and I often discuss the “everyone gets the same” phenomenon that’s sweeping our communities.  In an effort to protect fragile self-esteems, every child must be recognized, everyone gets a trophy, and everyone wins. Please tell me how the heck it builds self-esteem when your child gets things she does not deserve!  

Immediate Gratification

That is not pouring concrete and letting it set, creating a strong foundation of self-worth, drive, and motivation. That is loading up a sundae with whipped cream.  And guess what?  Not only is it unhealthy, but it melts!!  It looks awfully high at first, but it lasts all of five minutes before turning to mushy goo.

My neighbor Cheryl is one of the most put-together, secure, and confident people I know.  She is always laughing, positive, and happy, but also very focused and strict, in an incredibly loving way.  Her daughter is in fifth grade and plays basketball.  During one game, her daughter decided to zone on her shoes instead of the game, gave no effort at all, and even stomped her foot when the ball was stolen from her.  After the game (which her team lost), the coach followed his tradition of giving each player a star pin: Best Effort, Best Running, Most Points, etc. Well, Cheryl had to bite a hole through her lip as her daughter got a star for Best Sportsmanship.

As soon as they got into the car after the game, Cheryl turned around and faced her child. “Do you really think you put forth any effort or sportsmanship during that game?  Do you think stomping your foot earns you that star?”  Her daughter didn’t even think hard before replying, “No ma’am.”  So Cheryl said, “Give me that star.  Next practice, you are returning it to Coach and telling him you didn’t earn it.”

Cheryl held her ground and consistency, making her daughter give it back at the next practice.  And did the Coach coo, “Oooh, it’s okay, honey, you’ll earn it next time”  Nope.  He backed Cheryl up and told her daughter, “You are right to give this back.  You didn’t earn it.”    

So get rid of the TV, the latest coveted war game, the trophies for simply showing up at a track meet, and any soppy attitude.  When you make your child earn what he wants, you are giving a tremendous gift.  

You create a strong, independent, driven person. I know we enjoy indulging our children, but we confuse this with love. It is not love. It’s harmful and doesn’t meet their needs.  I know you know it.  You can see it in their behavior.

Do the right thing.  Meet your children’s needs.  Teach real love, respect, and responsibility.  Give your child a true sense of self-esteem and self-worth.  There may be a few tears and pain now, but if you wait until they have to learn this on their own, the pain will be one hundred times greater.  For you and them.